Shopsmith ad in popular woodworking magazine questionable

Safety issues are always our own personal responsibility, and i know that it’s obvious this ad is advertising sandpaper products, but there is still something businesses should do to make certain the ad content doesn’t mask the inherent dangers surround a product, machine or method of work. This ad and another Shopsmith uses shows people working without adequate protection as do most magazine images. This, as I say, masks the dangers to present an image of freedom that doesn’t actually exist when using machines.
Did anyone else see this advert in Popular Woodworking this month? DSC_0001Did anyone else wonder why it said, “Seasoned professional or amateur? I wasn’t at all sure if there was one of those hidden meanings in the fact that she was wearing no dust mask and she was obviously using a sander that had no dust bag or extractor connected to the dust port at the rear end of the sander. Was this as it seemed to me, sort of ┬áirresponsible advertising. I thought perhaps I was missing something here and someone could explain to me some subtlety in the ad.

Here we see a woman sanding with protective glasses on ( I think) and no other protection. Of the three head protective pieces, which one would you most likely be wearing in this advertisement, she’s wearing eyeglasses only, which I think is also important but was this just a mistake?

A similar ad appears in Fine Woodworking but this time it’s a man wearing glasses but no dust mask and using a belt sander. This one doesn’t show the tail end though.

6 comments

  1. Mike Russo says:

    Sometimes I think we read too much into advertising. This ad is for sandpaper, I think, since the rest of the image is cut off. It’s not an ad for a training course in sanding technique. It’s not a public service announcement for the risks of inhaling sanding dust. It’s jut an ad for sandpaper. Good sandpaper makes sanding dust, so showing a dusty sander in use for the ad makes logical sense to me.

    I worry about all the comments I see around the web regarding safety issues in woodworking. If I was new to this craft, I wouldn’t want to ever start it. To get started with power tools, I need the expensive tools and tons of safety gear. To get started with power tools, I have less cost in tools, but then I might need to tune them, and then they get get dull and there are 1000 people saying their way to sharpen is best.

    What saddens me when I see an ad like this is that they are trying to design one advertisement that will cover all the possibilities of the “instant gratification” world we live in.

    – Want more information, here’s our website
    – Too lazy to type in a website, here’s our QR code.
    – Too lazy to read the words, look at the dusty picture, product must have something to do with sanding.
    – Too lazy to look for our product on the shelves, here’s what the packaging looks like.

    Our bodies are smart….too much dust from sanding, we’ll cough. Our minds are the problems. When we ignore the coughing, that’s when the problems start!

    • Paul Sellers says:

      I know you are right in some of this, but I just finished reading an email on the effects of wood dust from machines and it is a serious issue we somehow think we are immune to. Sometimes the cough is too late as one account with cancer attributed directly to machine dust attests too after suing his company for various aspects of neglect.

  2. McGlynnOnMaking says:

    I’m pretty sure there isn’t any actual sanding going on in the picture, but it’s certainly not well done. If you’re going to pose a picture it ought to be complete with the recommended safety gear. Or posed in a way that shows the sanding is already finished. Using a dirty sander with the dust bag missing is pretty lame.

    But you can’t really fault PWW for this. I doubt they have any editorial control over the content of advertisements. That’s a pretty competitive game.

  3. bob easton says:

    1) It is as others have said, simply an advert for sandpaper. (albeit poorly done)

    or…

    2) They were on a tight budget and didn’t have the dust mask, ear defenders, helmet, face shield, full-body Tyvek suit, gloves, and steel-toed shoes usually required for machine woodworking.

    or…

    3) She’s really hand sanding with a sanding block that just looks like a machine.

  4. Yes. you are probably right. Doesn’t take much to get it right though. But I’ve made mistakes too. I just thought that there was some hidden meeting. Another ad happened for Irwin where this guy was standing string into space because he had an Irwin saw blade.

Leave a Reply