Here I tackle another concern about an article about benchtop sanders in Fine Woodworking issue #221 September/October 2011 by Roland Johnson.

Right off the bat Johnson states up front in the title that Benchtop sanders “…tackle trimming and smoothing quicker than hand tools do – with no sharpening needed.” That’s absolutely not the truth. What he might be better saying is that these machines substitute for skill and the results are therefor dumbed down standards. He fails on all fronts, as is a regular imbalance with this magazine and as was the case in the Bandsaw article previous post, to point out that you must wear a dust mask constantly and should wear one for an hour after all machines are switched off. That there are many other health risks involved with each one of these machines. He fails to point out that the accuracy drastically diminishes when using these types of machine sanders yet through images and text suggest that you can flush and fit drawers, boxes and doors and such with the same accuracy as hand tools which just not true. Whereas there is some truth to these sanders having limited usefulness for certain more perfunctory  tasks, they in no way equal hand tool methods and I will gladly prove that in any test they or anyone wants to present to me.

All in all, what I really want to say to any woodworker unused to this type of machine is don’t think that they are better than hand tools, but see them more as complementary in some small way for occasional tasks.

 

 

 

 

Don’t think that they will give the accuracy in making and fitting drawers and doors into recesses and openings. In skilled hands they might, but planes do it exponentially better. Tread with caution with sanders of all types they carry potential for all manner of respiratory problems no matter how good your extraction.

1 Comment

  1. Trevor Walsh on 12 October 2011 at 8:06 pm

    I’m glad to see a post on this, I almost choked when reading this one, and the one in PopWoodMag about Rigid’s newfangled multi-sander.



  • Kurt on A Gem of a RemnantAnd here I thought I was the only one who found this to be true.
  • Adam on Someone Wrote MeReally interesting discussion here. Could be just semantics, but I think machine woodworking is more of an ability. Something that pretty much all humans have - to be able to feed…
  • Stuart Woodcock on Someone Wrote MeHaving just started my first large project, a 3.5m x 0.85m outdoor table. I have watched a lot of Paul's videos to gain knowledge and inspiration. I can tell you from a novice pers…
  • Stephen Tyrrell on The Draw of Skilled HandsIt goes back much further than that. It was written in the 1920's and has been recorded many many times. Still being recorded by modern swing bands today. A great song and a great…
  • Stephen Tyrrell on Someone Wrote MeIt may be true that your efforts will not influence the mass producers Paul, but you have encouraged, tutored and trained thousands of "lifestyle" woodworkers in a craft that they…
  • Michael McGinnis on Someone Wrote MeThe book "The Perfectionists: How Precision Engineers Created the Modern World", by Simon Winchester, describes very well how we ended up the way we are today; without the skilled…
  • David on Hissy Snake ProjectPaul thanks for the video. How long did you make your Hissy Snake ? I guess it's about 18 inches. There might be a specific length to get the correct wiggle ? Thanks again Dave