PICT0034-168x225.jpgMore tales on dovetails
Some years back, about 1965, Derik (correct spelling ‘cos his dad couldn’t read or write) and I went to a house to price some work. My older mentor master joiner was talking to the lady who wanted some cabinet work for the dining area and needed some silverware drawers making. As things progressed favourably, Derik came to the point of costs and so asked the lady what kind of joinery she wanted. Being a bit of a shirker, he was avoiding dovetailing the corners. Derik said, “What would you like, an ordinary common dovetail or a neat little brad well punched? The lady replied, “We always have the best. We’ll have the neat little brad well punched.”
DSC_0085A couple of years ago I went by the Trend booth at the North of England Woodworking Show. Like US shows, British shows are mostly about the bottom line sales numbers not so much teaching and training, with demonstrators as add ons to improve the outward appearance of what is little more than a trade show . I think there are exceptions. The European Woodworking Show has many good presenters and a good balance of the creative with the commerce.

It usually takes about twenty minutes to walk around most shows, but every so often there is something interesting to see. In the shortfall I often find myself staring bemusedly at the machine world’s “expert woodworkers” setting up for a demo and before long I find myself yawning watching a router and jig cut dovetails and other different joints. It’s the extremes surrounding dovetail cutting that creates the greatest intrigue at international levels. DSC_0562To date, I haven’t found a single person who could not make a dovetail by hand. In some cases the standard is there at the very first cut, with others, it takes a few goes because of the confusion surrounding the idea of pins and tails, which sections are angled, what are the angles and where do the squares and so on come in. There is no sector of the work world that I can single out and say these have the most difficulty. What I do notice in general is that those who were raised and work purely in a two-dimensional world with little or no hands-on have more difficulty working three dimensionally for a short period. As most education and educationalists dictate a minimalist view of art and craft, that’s not likely to change in the near future. Near future directly impacts long-term changes so it does seem that such changes must take place outside of conventional educational establishments, which makes it a very narrow margin to influence those who might be best in an art and craft world.

6 Comments

  1. James Becwar on 24 May 2013 at 5:01 pm

    So I have to ask, whats the neat little brad well punched?



    • Paul Sellers on 24 May 2013 at 5:40 pm

      In the Uk we call a small finish nail a pin, a panel pin or a brad. Well punched means to set the head just under the surface with a nail punch or set before filling with wood filler or putty. Usually this is for painted finishes, but not always.



  2. Jeremy Buehler on 24 May 2013 at 8:47 pm

    So, looking at the top photo in the post, of the beautifully contrasted half-blind dovetails, I got to wondering…. Is it an aesthetic guideline when making half-blind dovetails to make the width of the narrow end of the pins the same as the distance from the end of the tail to the drawer front? Or was it in this case, coincidence?



  3. Paul Sellers on 27 May 2013 at 11:26 am

    I believe he did. Funnily enough, I have made several too, and wrote a small booklet on how to make a simple pine casket. It has dovetailed corners and wrought iron handles. It’s lined with cotton in white and has padding with dimples. All part of the work I have done.



    • Greg Vrana on 27 May 2013 at 6:13 pm

      Hi Paul, Is your booklet on casket making available? My interest has been piqued since seeing this video. Thanks



  4. mr Chris on 28 May 2013 at 4:27 pm

    Hi Paul,
    hope when I come on your October course, you will send me home able to do that, cutting them with my newly sharpened by me tenon saw.



  • Paul Keane on Working AloneI must say your website is excellent with lots of information on how to work with and improve my wood working skills. Due to the lockdown I have build a workbench, I have been look…
  • Dan on Branching outSteve, was that the one on display inside a ranger station in California? If so, I have seen that as well. Definitely worth a look to anybody interested. Keep well, everybody.
  • Gary on Working AloneYou are not alone when you go home to your partner at the end of each day. The same person you saw when you awoke this-morning. They're even with you in many ways when you're apart…
  • Paul Sellers on Edge Sharpening Under £10Is it "cheap" plates or 'less expensive' or 'low cost' plates? There is a difference here. Mylow cost plates in all gritt=s are holding up well after almost four months to date. My…
  • Paul Sellers on Edge Sharpening Under £10I might suggest something different here. I think that with the larger diamonds to top angular points fracture more readily and in a sense, create a sort of plateaued top which is…
  • Richard C on Edge Sharpening Under £10with the cheap plates, I find that yes, they wear very quickly initially, but then 'settle'. another thing I've found is that it's possible to scratch the grit off completely if yo…
  • Samuel on Working AloneThere’s a childlike joy in only having the bare essentials in tools and knowing them and admiring them.