Heard it Said…

…90% of woodworking is knowing how to fix your mistakes.

When a man starts working wood to live off what he earns, making becomes a resource to others. This is mostly because what he makes improves the life of another in some way, large or small. Being a solution is the way of life to the artisan and he and she is the vehicle through which the solution arrives. What I have enjoyed about wood is its predictable unpredictability. Just when you think you understand it, it seems apt to change its reliability. Here again, the artisan becomes the solution in that as soon as a problem presents itself, the maker seems unable to ignore the possibility and probability that he will become the solution. I say ‘he’ because I can only speak from my own perspective as a man having worked for a lifetime with men in what has been a male-dominated craft. That being the case, and having seen so little change in my 55 years, I am not sure whether I personally will see much change evidence over the remaining years of my life. Even though I have tried to enhance the future of woodworking as a non gender-specific craft it seems more apt to remain a male dominant craft even though I know and have heard of no situation where women have been held back by anyone.

Minute by minute, wood keeps on presenting problems to me. It splits off with no pressure beyond the surrounding air that’s still and quiet. It changes colour in places that were once totally balanced to become totally unbalanced. Joint lines perfected by shoulder planes and chisel cuts gape open for no apparent reason and then that smooth and smoothed surface develops a texture like a vintage washboard.

I recently made a cabinet that had an even gap a penny thickness all the way around and when I painted it with a water-based paint the gap closed up completely. The natural solution was to plane to refit and then repaint. I didn’t. I just left it overnight and the next day the door had shrunk back to its former perfection plus a couple of thou’.

Woodworkers often say that 90% of woodworking is knowing how to fix your mistakes. The issue for me is this! When you pick up a mallet and chisel to chop a section of wood, do you at that point ‘become‘ a wood worker? Well, the answer really is a resounding no! What you became was a person who worked some wood. But if you intend to go beyond this chiseling session to make a part of your life include woodworking regularly then as soon as you picked up the chisel and mallet, yes, you became a woodworker, albeit an inexperienced one. It’s at this point you begin learning what you can and cannot do with that chisel and mallet. You began learning what you could and could not do with wood. Someone asked recently whether they could glue two outer boards to an inner one to stabilise the tabletop. The answer was, of course, yes! The next question was could this questioner orient the grain at 90-degrees to the other two? The answer again was yes, but with the caveat that what was intended to stabilise the tabletop would now destabilize it and the result would likely be three separated sections of wood with some splitting and differences in thickness. You move to the plane and the handsaw and then the spokeshave. Here, your education begins. The wood splits somewhere and you realise that you need to fix some mistakes. The biggest mistake is the assumptions you have. The assumption that wood can be simply glued according to your own whim can look great for a few days, but soon the wood cannot move, will move and will warp and split. You have already given it away, sold it or whatever and your reputation is on the line. Such faults do not somehow disappear with your internal mental-delete button and no remedial action can correct the great forces of resistance. Surely archaic practices by primitives who knew not the computer era in digital realms could not know more than a college graduate! Well, they knew masses that we we know nothing of. I have seen many a student take a huge mallet and pound a tenon into a mortise only to see and hear great cracks appear.How can this be?

I say all of the above to say that you do not continue fixing the same mistakes over and over and you will indeed make fewer and fewer as you grow in your craft. And you do learn how to fix things too, that bit is true. I would just hate for anyone to think that they might be making mistakes for ever, that’s all.

As I have grown in experience I make fewer mistakes. That all too common phrase, “90% of woodworking is knowing how to fix your mistakes!” remains ridiculous, at least for the main part. The assumption is that you will always be making mistakes. Mistakes on a continuing basis, especially the same ones over and over, usually result from insensitivities in individuals who might well be, well, less sensitive to key areas of working than others are. Mental and physical attitudes affect the way we work. I watch the slight build of a woman woodworker working with her tenon saw and she guides with perfect adjustment in anticipation of obstruction. Another takes the full-bodied weight of shoulder mass and shoves the saw mercilessly into the wood and achieves a cut that looks like a rat chewed its way through. One needs corrective surgery and part replacement and the other none. A man in my class refused to anchor his work in the vise after frequent warnings of the danger he was to himself. Ultimately the wood slipped and he ran a super sharp chisel across the back of each of his fingers and the blood was amazingly quantitative. Many stitches and two hours later he returned with an inability to continue the course. The mistake was fixed by surgery work but not at all without great cost.

So in reality it’s not true at all. 90% of woodworking is fixing mistakes for the rest of your woodworking life but adjusting from the inexperience level to the experienced, where you begin anticipating the probabilities that something could and will often go wrong if you don’t do this or do that. Experience tells you what to expect and you taker precautions to ensure a good outcome.

Before beginning any project, I think through every stage to anticipate what will happen at the various junctures. I divide the passage if making into subassemblies. I rely on my now built-in radar experience in the way we all do in every aspect of life. If I were to continue to repair my mistakes with my driving or riding my bike, and all others did the same, chaos would be the result in an already over-chaotic world. I rely on my experience then not to repair mistakes but to ensure I don’t make them in the first place or at least minimise the possibities. So, will the glue-up work if I do this or that first? A small question ahead of time with big consequences later on whilst in the process. Judicious planning obviates most if not all of the potential problems

Again it’s less to do with you and more to do with the wood. Learning how to fix your mistakes is just a cute saying. Most woodworkers learn the important stuff early on. I think it’s more a sloppy catchall and cover-up as are many other terms used throughout the woodworking world. I prefer things to be just plainly stated. Another bed partner to this is the one where someone said to someone, “I’ve been working so hard!” and the listener said, “Don’t work hard, work smart!” Well, why not work hard, diligently, and, well, smart too?

21 thoughts on “Heard it Said…”

  1. Great points. I recently learned from a new mistake. I was making drawers for a tool chest which called for, instead of a pull knob, a 1″ hole drilled next to the top of the front so the upper 1/4 of the hole cut through the top side, so the finger pull is basically 3/4 of a hole. When using my brace and 1″ auger, it went well at first and then about halfway down ripped right side of the upper portion of the front off. I flipped the piece over and tried to clean up the other part from breaking and then the other half split off. So I stopped, glued the pieces and clamped them, then left the clamps on to finish drilling. I’ll NEVER make that mistake again(I’ll know to clamp before drilling something like that).
    It reminds me of an old western movie called Valdez is Coming. The bad guys tie Valdez to a wooden cross and leave him in the desert. After wandering around, he finds two trees too narrow to get through, so he runs full speed to charge into themto attempt to break the cross tied to his back. He succeeds but the sharp parts of teh branches go into his back and he screams. When a guy finds him later, he saysto Valdez, “Where did you think the wood was gonna go when it broke?” I am often reminded of this part when woodworking, what did I THINK was gonna’ happen?

  2. Paul, As part of my project planning process I would like to know if two, 2×4″s can be joined with glue along the 2″ edge to ultimately make 2×6″ tennoned rails such as would be used in the workbench build. I’m unsure if this is a good way to make wider stock which will be tenoned. Larger stock is hard to find for me and I’m trying to avoid a joint failure. Thanks for sharing your experience!

    1. Jon – I hope my reply doesn’t deny you a reply from Paul, but I can say that I did exactly what you propose when I built my bench 2 years ago and it’s still rock solid and stable (as flat and square as when I made it) and stands up to the use & abuse I give it. If there’s a downside, I didn’t find it yet.

    2. Jon,
      I often join boards this way. The thing I do is use dominos (by festool) depending on how long the overall length is , is what I use to determine how many I use. I glue them in and glue all along the flat edge also-. Good luck!

  3. Hi Paul, I’ve just bought a Stanley 78 rebate plane off eBay. It needs a clean up and I’d like to re-flatten and polish the sole.

    Now, when initialising a smoothing plane you recommend taking a rasp to it to “break the edges” i.e put a slight chamfer on them. Does this also apply when tuning up a rebate plane?

    Many Thanks

  4. Mistakes vs problems. Yes I may have been shoddily getting on board the wrong idea, but as you said less mistakes come with experience… but only as a “woodworker” ie someone pushing to improve. It’s easy when you can’t quite master something but want to try to do it,,even when it’s going wrong.. and somehow expect the result to be different — I have never found that doing something in the same way and the same attitude as a failed attempt ever produced something good.
    I guess my feeling on most things is that an informed and determined plan of workmanship can have some flaws in the doing of it,,, but if the object is fit for purpose and made to function with deftness, strength and preservation of its inherent beauty; I still can have pride in it. It doesn’t happen for me much.

  5. William T Willmore

    I was told by an old carpenter from GA. who was “blind in one eye and can’t see from the other” A man who taught me alot! “Any carpenter can make a mistake, but the good ones can hide em.”

  6. I can appreciate speaking from experience, but there was a lot more paternalistic prose than philosophy or teaching. Perhaps a concise paragraph or haiku would suffice next time.

  7. I’ve been working wood 60 years plus, you must think ahead of most probable things that can happen or had happened in the past. No peice is perfect but strive for it.

  8. Colin J Atterbury

    The only problem I see is this article is the non-gender based BS that keeps being push down everyone’s throat.

  9. Paul
    I very much enjoyed this blog. It has been said to “err is human”. But it is also learning from our errors that propels us forward. When I was a young surgeon, my father, also a surgeon, told me that “an experienced surgeon is one who has seen and made enough mistakes that he has an idea of how to avoid them in the future”. 40 years later I offer this same advice to the young man and women that I train. Learn and correct for the future, do not just plan on patching everything up time and again


  10. I really enjoy your thoughts. Each time I start a project I bring with me the memory and knowledge of mistakes I made on last projects and try not to make those same mistakes. At the end of a project I usually have a mental list of things I will do different on the next project. Thank you for the video on building your frame saw. I am going to build two of those. Also I think that little Stanley marking knife you have is literally perfect.

  11. Paul: I’m a wheelchair bound person “practicing” woodworking. (I refuse to use the word disabled when describing myself.) My condition has improved my woodworking skills along with help from to your videos. I have come to realize I now make fewer mistakes than I did in my past life. My rationale is simply this; after several hour in my workshop, I tire easily. Once I sense that I stop what I’m doing and start cleaning up the place for the next day. Sometimes it’s simply sharpening a plane blade or chisel. Other times I’m picking out wood for the next day. Since I refuse to use power tools, retrieving seldom used tools for future work is my goal. And, as always, picking up the shavings and dust to I created that day. In short, when I’m tired, I make mistakes. When I’m fresh at the beginning of the day, I do my best work. (And I have learned to plane boards with my trusty No.5 sitting down!) Thank you for all you do. It’s sincerely appreciated!

  12. Robert Brunston

    You have to learn to be good at fixing and hiding mistakes if you want your work to look good.
    Wood does what wants. You can plan to the smallest detail and some problem will pop up that you could not have anticipated.
    Thank you Paul.

  13. Helpful points about experience leading to fewer mistakes. That said, I would benefit from Paul’s suggestions as to how to fix some common mistakes that we less experienced hobbyists actually do make. Taking dents out with the use of an iron was certainly useful to me. But there are so many others.

    In making the bookshelves, I found that I had cut the tenon shoulders on the two arches 1/8″ to short, meaning there would be 1/16″ gaps on each joint. I could make it 1/8″ on one side and fashion a shim (easiest), or fashion 1/16″ shims on each joint (more difficult), or I could cut the arches in half and add a central shim of a contrasting wood that was 1/8″ + kerf. Suggestions?

    I have this quote framed and hanging in my shop:

    “The master has failed more times than the beginner has even tried.”
    –Stephen McCranie

    Finally, as for gender issues, they are, of course real. Paul, you may not have seen any overt behavior that prevented women from entering the craft. But the society in which we live has established fairly rigid gender roles, which only recently are being challenged collectively and with some success. We make the society in which we live; and we can always make it better.

    Thanks for an interesting post.

Comments are closed.

Privacy Notice

You must enter certain information to submit the form on this page. We take the handling of personal information seriously and appreciate your trust in us. Our Privacy Policy sets out important information about us and how we use and protect your personal data and it also explains your legal rights in respect of it. Please click here to read it before you provide any information on this form.