For more information on spokeshaves, see our beginner site Common Woodworking.

Muscle development in the hands

I meant to take pictures of a common problem with spokeshaves bedded at 40-45 degrees. This type includes almost all of the metal-cast models we know and love including Veritas and #151 models and more. People who tend to sharpen with micro bevels would best just sharpen a single bevel of 30-degrees. This gives an uncompromised edge with strength and sharpness equaling any micro bevel sharpening method because it delivers exactly the same physical cutting edge quality. I also recommend a honing guide for this because the short blade length plays havoc on untrained hands that have not yet developed hand and finger muscle and the resultant strength you get when development is achieved. Using a honing guide does give you the training that will reflect in the development of these key areas. To use a honing guide requires a additional extender to house the iron in as the iron itself is not long enough to hold in the guide and extend long enough to reach the stone for grinding. 

My reasons for suggesting this is not reversing people from adopting the freehand methods I prefer, but resolving practical issues. Because new woodworkers  do lack the strengths I speak of in their early development, they (my students all have this problem) they tend to lift the iron and deliver the wrong presentation angle to the sharpening plates. This then results in a sharper camber than with plane irons and when the iron is replaced in the body of the spokeshave, the over belly prevents the very cutting edge from reaching the wood and we end up with burnished wood not shaved wood and shavings. In some cases, the cutting edge lies compromised behind the fore aspect of the plane’s sole altogether and so it cannot possibly cut at all. Eventually of course you will want to freehand because of the slowness of loading the iron and setting it in the guide and all that that requires. By then you will have the right finger muscle for both strength and accuracy.
Cutting iron depth setting
Another issue not readily seen and known is pushing the iron out too much beyond the throat and the face of the sole. This can of course develop shavings too thick and heavy for the spokeshaves and the throat opening. That’s an obvious conclusion. The real problem seldom seen is that the iron protrudes and the heel (rear end) of the sole rides the wood and so pivots the presentation of the cutting edge away from its task. Because no shaving emerges from the throat, the tendency is foot advance the cutting iron more and more. Tipping the tool forward then takes a ripping and gouging cut and tipping it backwards rides the back edge of the bevel and the heel of the sole. I conclude then that greater accuracy is needed in maintaining the bevel of the tool and if a camber is preferred, as I adjure people to aim for, they should strive for a shallow camber and not an elliptical one with the minor axis closer to the edge, which is a mistaken development and often a bad habit.

3 Comments

  1. Jacob Butler on 17 October 2012 at 8:08 pm

    I use a honing ‘guide’ with small blades like this, but it’s just a piece of 2×1″ with a saw kerf to hold the blade. It works really well and you can press down hard and also do the rounded bevel with no problem.
    It just need to fit loosely, the downward pressure holds it firmly in place.



    • gazpal on 18 October 2012 at 12:13 pm

      It’s a very accurate method too 🙂



  • Don Hummer on If You Need a ReasonWorking as a framing carpenter in high production work in Arizona built my strength and endurance. My brother in law was a gym rat. I had to pour some concrete at his house for a s…
  • Thomas on Plywood Workbench AnniversaryThank you! that's a good idea :-)
  • Paul Sellers on It’s All in the JoineryThe main reason never to hollow grind though is one) the general and unnecessary excessive loss of steel, two) overheating the steel and even burning it, three) the need of some ki…
  • Mark D. Baker on If You Need a ReasonFor about 40 years, I was involved in heavy construction. I gauged my work effort by my food consumption and weight each Monday morning and the following Friday. Each Monday, if my…
  • Ed on It’s All in the JoineryI think they hollow grind because A) New tools are almost universally thick blades, often cryogenically hardened B) They believe that the only way to have a sharp edge is from the…
  • JOe on If You Need a ReasonYou raise a good point Paul about physical labor. I faced a dilemma back in the late 1990s. I had finished my schooling and moved back home to start my career. My grandmother lived…
  • Joe on Furniture For Your HomeThanks Paul. Looking forward to it all. Any chance you can give us a vlog walkthrough on the ideas bouncing around in your head? I'm not trying to get you to commit to anything but…