My Knife is Unique!

P1010669There are probably hundreds of different knives around made, intended or adapted for working wood with and I have made a couple of dozen through the decades that worked just fine. Some of you have noticed that my Stanley Folding Pocket Knife is different than the usual powder coated Stanley I started out espousing as the best knife in the world. Of course knife makers have every right to denounce me as some kind of heretic were I indeed talking about those made by the brilliant makers around the world and so I qualify my statement by saying pound for pound the Stanley knife I use in my daily work is the knife I reach for and I have yet to find one that matches its functionality on my bench.

The original knife with powder coated for grip
The original knife with powder coated for grip

I have used the same knife over many years and in my mind the only way to really review any woodworking tool is longterm over a number of years of daily use. No tool review I have ever read in a magazine has ever done this and that’s the difference between what we try to do.

With the powder coating removed the knife is still fully comfortable and comfortable to use.
With the powder coating removed the knife is still fully comfortable and comfortable to use.

My knife started wearing through the outer powder coat on key wear areas to the point that the unevenness felt less smooth and comfortable in my hand. I removed the thin coating all over and buffed the new surface with a polishing mop on an electric grinder. The end result is an extra special finish that took my knife to new heights. Ten minutes work or less and I have my own treatment. I would like this knife in brass all the more but this works fine. In my view this is about the best joinery knife there is. I have other knives (top) I really like too, all of those shown here have added functionality in my knife collection and so different uses.

P1010718

In the hand, this knife is the very best. It’s thin blade gets tight in into the corners of dovetail tail and pin recesses yet I have only broken one blade in ten years or so that I can recall. I resharpen them for more than a year and could do so for longer but I like to keep length in my work. For shoulder lines to tenons and housing dadoes up against the square it seems to me invincible.

28 comments on “My Knife is Unique!

  1. I’ve been using mine for about a year now I think, I bought a spare as well just to use for rough work so I can keep my good one fresh. I had to do a little bit of work on mine to get the to halves of the casting to close neatly.
    I think with the amount of sales you have generated for Stanley they should at least send you a special edition Paul Sellers solid brass version. Or better still a gold version 🙂

  2. I wasn’t too crazy about those knives when I first used them. Then I noticed the profile of Paul’s blade was different than the one that came in my Stanley 10-049. I had the “heavy duty” blade (11-040, aka sheepsfoot) that is substantially thicker and consequently harder to keep right next to the square. The Utility Blade (11-041) is thinner, slices wood easier, and holds to the square much tighter. The lighter blade with it’s long point is also easier for me to precisely locate.

    I also didn’t like how thin the knife handle was until, again, I noticed how Paul holds his. Judging by the grip I was using on mine what I had in mind was slicing all the way through the board with the marking knife. That wasn’t working too well for me.

    Now my only problem is keeping enough of these knives around so I can find one at layout time. Mine tend to migrate as I cannot break the habit of putting a folding knife into my pocket when I’m done with it.

    Still, I’m a bit disappointed in them. I was SURE the difference in Paul’s work and mine came down to the knife but apparently something else is the cause. Does anyone know what brand of pencils he uses because THAT could be the key!

    John

    • I never fold my Stanley marking knife. Instead, I put the point into a wine bottle cork and place it in a small drawer beneath my work bench with other layout tools. The cork protects the sharp edge of the knife and also protects me when I reach into the drawer.

  3. Perhaps we could have a little fun completion who has the most unique knife, the prettiest the one the most, the one the lest blade swops etc
    mmmh got me thinking

  4. I must say so far this knife is a joy to use after I got used to holding it. I have a couple “pricey” ones with beautiful wood handles and spear point tips that I never use anymore since buying the 10 – 049 in a local Mom and Pop Hardware Store. Yes you can buy them from Amazon a little cheaper but unless you are buying a few things all together the saving’s isn’t there.

    Besides I like to Support the Locals when I can, having said that I need to buy another one for a spare and backup. I also like the idea of removing the powdercoat and buffing it out. I usually take the finish off of wood handles and use plain wax which I think feels a lot nicer in the hand.

    Paul did you use any special compound when you buffed your knife out or just let the wheel do it’s thing.

    Steve

  5. Paul, that knife is a telltale sign of someone’s involvement with you. I think Stanley should give you a royalty for helping promote it. I was at Lie-Nielsen’s open house last summer when I met a young man from New York that had a display booth. On his bench I saw your style knife and red handled mallet. So I asked where he had met you, and indeed he had. I pulled my knife out of my pocket to show him I belonged to the same school of thought!

  6. I received mine today via Swiss post I purchased it from the UK Amazon.I had read what Paul had written about it here on the blog and thought I might give it a try. At first blush it feels a bit on the small size for my hands,the blade super sharp with a decent lock holding it extended.I will give it a chance before I give it a yea or nay.The price is acceptable considering the build quality.

  7. I had a very nice and extremely sharp knife which I abandoned after using Paul’s recommendation. It works great and fits nicely in the hand. It is amazing that such a useful knife is so inexpensive. Thanks you again and again, Mr Sellers! Yes, I guess you could say this old man is a fanboy!

  8. I live in the U.S. ordered on eBay from Big Red Tool Box, think they are in UK. Now they have not arrived yet, I will report when they do. The product is 010-598. I am thinking Mr. Sellers should, at least get one free from Stanley. Take care.

    Mike

  9. I ordered one from the Big Red Tool Box in the UK through Amazon; $12.43 USD and free shipping. It was shipped 6 January and arrived yesterday, 26 January. Do a search in Amazon for “Stanley 010-598 pocket knife” to find it. The replacement blades are $7.99 USD for a 3-pack including shipping. The 10-049 replacement is $3.84 USD for one blade.

  10. I looked for the layout knife you recommend and use, 10-958, according to your 2012 blog post. Could find a 10-598, to come from UK, but was not absolutely sure it was the correct knife. See, it looks like you exchanged 95 for 58. Could it be that simple and the two numbers are so ntended to associate with the knife you love?

  11. I was never able to get this knife, so I use a #1 chip carving knife from pfeil. I’m very happy with it, but I don’t have the stanley knife to compare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *