The saw handle on my R Groves rip had been damaged and poorly repaired. It happens and it’s not uncommon at all to find a saw horn damaged. The repair popped off at some time and I have put off the repair proper until I found the right time; that’s something I rarely do because I like solutions in time not late. I have been packing away my tools, categorising them, archiving some, destining some for repair and keeping primary users close to my right hand. My Groves always take priority.

The handle is beech. It’s smooth as silk and even with the chunk missing it still feels OK, but OK is not quite right so today was the day for the repair. Whoever repaired this before intended I am sure to develop a flat plane but instead  created an undulating surface with a large hollow in the centre. Not really a good gluing surface.

I developed a registration surface by eyeballing the angle and creating a flat to a piece of scrap wood.







The chisel made the primary cuts to some beech I found to cut the repair piece from.

I then planed the flat true with a #4.







Clamping the newly formed guide in the vise and then the saw handle to the guide made everything solid enough for me to pare cut the surface dead level.








A few stokes with the chisel brought the highs low to create a decent mating surface.







I used a more viscous super-glue (Cyanoacrylate) and accelerator to set the glue almost immediately on contact. It worked perfectly first time. Applying the glue to one half and spraying the accelerator to the other works great.


After a minute or two I removed most of the excess with a small saw.












I then used a chisel and a rasp to refine the shape so it conformed with the remainder of the handle.










The chisel, bevel down, worked best for the coved parts…




…and the scraper came in for truing and levelling.



The file and rasp helped me to shape the additional shaping.

Lastly the sandpaper gave me a very smooth texture that matched the original.





Now it fits and feels good in my hand as if its always been there.







All that’s left now is to change the colour and apply a coat or two of boiled linseed oil or just a wax finish thzt will blend and tone the colour and feel.

First colour added…

…then widening the band and…

I used furniture touch-up felt tips to add the colour I needed. Two colours did the trick mostly but I needed to dd a little darkness and used brown Sharpie pen for the final depth of colour.

…adding a little darker and…

…a brown Sharpie took care of the final colour.









Feels good, looks good and by golly it is good!

Here’s the final look I was looking for.




  1. Paul Cleary on 18 November 2017 at 7:54 pm

    Thanks for this post as one of my Disston saws has the same handle problem.
    It’s a minor annoyance when I use it, but I have always been nervous about fixing the handle in case I screw up and make it worse.

  2. Paul Walker on 20 November 2017 at 8:39 pm

    And by golly it is good. Mackesons If I remember correctly?

  3. Matt Sims on 20 November 2017 at 10:17 pm

    By golly it does you good!

  4. Joe on 21 November 2017 at 7:27 pm

    Thanks Paul. I have a similar repair I need to make to my father’s Diston saw he kept behind the seat of his 56 Ford pick.

    I noticed you used cyanoacrylate based glue with accelerator (presumable so you could finish the repair instead of waiting). Do you notice any long term difference between CA glue vs. the common glue you normally use to glue up wood?

    • Paul Sellers on 21 November 2017 at 8:56 pm

      I have found that many repairs seem to seat better and remain firm with superglue whereas PVA seems to have a certain elasticity for certain repairs like this one that’s all.

  5. Tone on 3 March 2018 at 7:23 pm

    I didn’t realise that such repairs were possible. Impressive.

    Today, after re-reading a couple of Paul’s articles, I reshaped the handle on my “modern” Spear & Jackson12″ brass back tenon saw. I’m guessing the saw is from the 1970’s by the modernist, square-ish, boxy appearance and the handle is rosewood (dark, with a red hue inside) . The saw had a striking look but I found the appearance, feel and heavy weight of the saw disappointing & unappealing to the extent that I stopped using it. Now it looks and feels great! It has become something uniquely mine, somewhat handcrafted and remade to fit my hand. I love it. And it looks more expensive. What a transformation! Thanks Paul 🙂

  6. Claudio on 11 October 2018 at 6:56 am

    I have a problem like this in a saw handle… but wow, I don’t think there is a way for me to be able to do that. That looks amazing, but I might make the handle worse, I don’t feel the confidence to try this.

    • Paul Sellers on 11 October 2018 at 9:54 am

      Not much risk if it’s already missing.

  • Keith Small on Finally Sorted My ToolsHi Paul, after having sorted out my hand tool kit to begin my journey for hand tool woodworking, I am looking for one more tool. The No.71 router plane. I was wondering if you woul…
  • Carlos Alvarado on Finally Sorted My ToolsIt has taken me a while but I have finally started doing some work to be able to store my tools. I definitely do not have the amount of tools that you have Paul but I do have more…
  • revwayne on Finally Sorted My ToolsI've been reorganizing my shop; sharpening chisels, plane irons, scrapers, saws and edged tools; moving tools in benches to match my ever-changing workflow and builds. Rag in a can…
  • Mark D. Baker on Finally Sorted My ToolsAloha Paul, With this 'shut-down', being shut-in, takes on a new feeling. It's all good, to be healthy and safe. But soon you run out of things to tidy up, to sharpen, to draft and…
  • Gene Foster on Finally Sorted My ToolsPaul I discovered your videos at Woodcraft. Then I bought your woodworking books and have been following you on You Tube. Thanks. I built my own bench 30 years ago but I want to bu…
  • BigD on Finally Sorted My ToolsMy grandfather was a carpenter for 30 years and I always loved going into his garage and smelling the smells that were all around me. The only other smells I really remember from m…
  • Richard J Garrow on Working AloneHi Paul, and other writers and readers, I have been mostly a reader, I love to read Paul's blog, and a lot of time is spent reading the replies he gets. If is helpful to get other…